#SixWordPeerReview

This hashtag has been making the rounds on Twitter, pithy illustrations of the flaws of double-blind peer review. Some of the entries hit a little close to home...

Author made all required revisions. Reject. #SixWordPeerReview
— Eva Amsen (@easternblot) January 21, 2014

Your conclusions are distasteful to me. #SixWordPeerReview
— Flavia (@FlaviaFescue) January 22, 2014

Can't quite explain why but reject #SixWordPeerReview
— Zachary Lesser (@ZacharyLesser) January 21, 2014

Badly dangling modifier on p. 10. #SixWordPeerReview
— Bruce Holsinger (@burnablebooks) January 22, 2014

Let's pretend I don't know you #SixWordPeerReview
— Sarah Kendzior (@sarahkendzior) January 21, 2014

...my own included.

Do something different with this text. #SixWordPeerReview
— S.J. Pearce (@homophonous) January 22, 2014